Great Lakes Home Remodeling
Great Lakes Home Remodeling

Pros and Cons of Metal Roofs Per An Insurance Carrier!

October 27, 2024

Great Lakes Home Remodeling met with an Anonymous Insurance Carrier recently and she was willing to share some inside information with us as to the opinion of which was better - Traditional Roofing or Metal Roofing Systems. The ultimate answer was from their prospective was that the benefits of a stone coated metal roof may very well outweigh the traditional asphalt shingle roof system when a homeowner considers the potential stone coated metal roof lifespan.

Deciding on the type of roofing material for your home is a great deal more than just about home aesthetics. A roof system should be considered for it's longevity, durability and overall home protection a roof will offer. This is where the age-old debate of traditional roofing shingles vs metal roofs comes into debate.

Both roof types have their merits and downsides when it comes to a roof system. Making the roof choice is dependent on several roof factors, including budget, roof style, climate, and roof slope. Let us now explore and compare traditional shingles and metal roofs offer diversity and potential advantages when it comes to a roofing system for your home which will help you make an informed roof system decision.


Metal Roof Pros, Contributing Benefits and Key Advantages

  • Most compelling selling point: Longevity - metal roofs can last between 40 to 80+ years, significantly longer than the 7-20-year lifespan of a traditional asphalt shingle roof
  • Next Important factor: Metal roofs are extremely weather and seasonal resilient, including strong hail, winds, heavy snow and even wildfires - causing metal roofs to offer the most robust roof choice for almost any climate
  • Pocketbook advantage: Metal roofing can save a homeowner upwards of 40% and more on energy costs
  • Environmental concern factor: Metal roofing materials are made from recycled content and are 100% recyclable at the end of their life, making them the number one environmentally friendly choice to reducing their carbon footprint on the earth
  • Weather resistant: Metal roofs offer the most superior impact resistance including hail and tree branches
  • Fire resistant: Metal roofs are noncombustible and have a Class A fire rating (the absolute most fire resistant roof material)

In comparing stone coated metal roofs and traditional roofing shingles, it is clear a metal roof system has its advantages to make a metal roof an attractive choice for homeowners today. However, their is a slightly higher initial investment upfront to consider, but ultimately, choosing between a metal roof and shingles will bring your home’s appearance and performance to the ultimate long term permanent solution.

Before making a roof system change or decision, it is always recommended to consult with a professional roofing contractor to discuss the best roof system for your home. A roof professional can provide valuable roof insights and help calculate the long-term savings to help make an informed roofing choice. In addition, insurance companies and the IRS may provide roof material discounts and tax deductions based on the type of roofing material chosen.

Investing in your home’s roof system is a critical decision which impacts your overall property’s value, cost-efficiency and long term safety. If you're ready for the Real Roof Deal when it comes to a new roof call the professionals at Great Lakes! Currently we have locations in Ohio, Michigan and Indiana! Call 1-800-715-ROOF for more information! AND P.S If you find we're not serving your area call any ways - we might be soon and can get you the last roof you'll ever need for your home!

Read more articles

More Questions?
Check out our FAQ →
GET A PRICE NOW

See your roof estimate in 60 seconds

DemandIQ pulls your roof's measurements from satellite imagery and returns an installed price range — no rep visit required.

Get my estimate →~60 seconds · no sales call

Let's get to work.

We deliver dependable solutions with craftsmanship, honesty, and care. Protect your home today and for years to come.

CheckExcellence in Design, Installation, and Service
CheckFully Licensed, Bonded, & Insured
CheckAffordable Financing Options Available
CheckCustomer Service Above All Else
CheckTop-Rated Local Contractor
4.8/5485 Reviews

Ready to get started?

Get your free estimate today!
First Name *
Last Name *
Phone Number *
Zip Code *
Email Address *
How can we help? *
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
No items found.